Panel question 05 of 8

Are data centers in Oakland or the Cow Palace a good idea?

This corpus can't answer that — but it can tell you how the question goes wrong.

The field reporting here is Wisconsin and Michigan. Nobody in it has studied Bay Area siting, and borrowing Midwest conclusions for a California grid, water table, and land market would be exactly the kind of confident-and-wrong move the panel is trying to avoid.

What does transfer is procedural. Every site where the process was opaque — NDAs, deals disclosed after the fact — went badly for everyone, including the developer. The one with 60+ public meetings did not.

So the useful question locally isn't “data center: yes or no.” It's “who signed what, when did residents find out, and who pays if it's empty in ten years.”